Chapter 18 - The Honest Talk
That evening, after the movers had departed and Lily was asleep in her new upstairs bedroom surrounded by unpacked cardboard boxes and stuffed animals, Arthur and Clara sat together on the wooden steps of the back porch, watching the fireflies dance across the dark grass of their new yard.
Two glasses of lemonade sat between them on the cedar steps, catching the soft yellow glow of the porch lights. For a long time, neither of them spoke; they simply listened to the quiet rustle of the oak leaves in the summer breeze—a symphony of suburban peace that felt light-years away from the screeching sirens and gridlocked traffic of downtown Chicago.
Arthur turned his glass around in his hands, watching the condensation drip onto the wood. “I need to ask you something, Clara. And I want you to be completely honest with me, even if you think it might hurt my feelings.”
Clara turned her head toward him, pulling her knees up to her chest and wrapping her arms around her shins. “Ask me anything, Arthur.”
“When we first moved into the condo after the hospital, we said we were doing this as coparents—that we were putting the family back together for Lily’s sake so you wouldn't have to work yourself to death in Rogers Park.” Arthur paused, looking down at his hands. “We bought this house together. Our names are both on the deed as joint tenants with right of survivorship. I live in the master bedroom on the right, you live in the master suite on the left. But every morning when I wake up and see you in the kitchen, and every night when we sit out here like this… I realize that I don't just want to be your coparent, Clara. I want to be your husband again.”
He looked up into her eyes, his heart beating with a vulnerable, terrifying honesty he hadn’t felt since he was twenty years old asking her out on their first date.
“I know I broke your trust three years ago when I chose that M&A firm over our marriage,” Arthur continued softly. “I know a few months of cooking meals and fighting lawyers doesn't erase the loneliness you felt when I left you. I’m not asking you to forget the past. But I am asking if there is a place in your heart where you could ever see us putting those wedding rings back on our hands—not for Lily, but because you actually want to spend the rest of your life with me.”
Clara reached out in the darkness of the porch, her small, warm hand closing firmly over his large, calloused fingers. She didn't answer immediately; she looked out over the fireflies dancing in the yard, a soft, beautiful smile touching the corners of her mouth as a tear slipped down her cheek in the moonlight.
“Arthur,” Clara whispered, her voice husky with emotion as she leaned her head against his shoulder. “I never took my ring off my heart. I just put it in my jewelry box because looking at it made me miss the man you used to be before the money changed you. But that man came back the night Lily called him from a broken apartment. He came back, he fought for us, and he built us a home.”
May you like
She turned her face toward his, her eyes shining with a deep, restored love that had survived the darkest storms of their lives.
“Ask me again next summer, Arthur,” Clara said softly, brushing her lips gently against his jawline. “Ask me on the front porch when the oak trees are green again, and I’ll say yes before you even finish the sentence.”
