Chapter 14 - The Trial Begins
Courtroom 4B was packed to standing room only. The wooden benches of the gallery were filled with local journalists, legal analysts, and spectators drawn by the sensational tabloid headlines of the past month.
Judge Eleanor Holloway—a veteran family court judge with zero tolerance for courtroom theatrics—sat high on her bench, looking down at the two legal teams with a sharp, dissecting gaze.
“We are here to rule on the petitioner's emergency motion for temporary guardianship of the minors Mia, Chloe, and Lily Vance,” Judge Holloway announced, her gavel tapping once. “Mr. Henderson, you may call your first witness to establish the grounds of parental incompetence.”
Henderson rose, his silk suit catching the fluorescent lights. “Your Honor, we call Beatrice Vance—ah, Beatrice Miller, former residential governess to the Vance estate.”
Beatrice was led into the courtroom from the side door by a court bailiff. Because she was currently under felony indictment for child abuse and unlawful imprisonment, she wore a standard-issue county jail jumpsuit, though Victoria’s lawyers had managed to get her handcuffs removed for her testimony.
She took the witness stand, swearing on the Bible with a practiced, trembling solemnity designed to elicit sympathy.
“Ms. Miller,” Henderson began gently, pacing in front of the jury box. “During your twelve-month employment at the Vance estate, what was the true nature of Mr. Vance’s involvement with his daughters?”
“He was entirely absent, sir,” Beatrice said, dabbing at her dry eyes with a tissue. “He worked fourteen-hour days. When he was home, he ignored the children. He couldn't bear to look at them because they reminded him of his late wife. The poor girls were profoundly disturbed, acting out violently, refusing to speak. I was forced to use strict behavioral containment protocols just to keep them from hurting themselves.”
“And when you reported these severe psychological issues to Mr. Vance,” Henderson prompted, “what was his response?”
“He threatened me!” Beatrice cried out, looking toward the judge. “He told me to keep them quiet by any means necessary so they wouldn't disrupt his business calls! When I refused to use illegal sedation, he manufactured false abuse allegations, hired a waitressing mistress to replace me, and had me thrown in jail to ruin my credibility!”
A murmur of shock rippled through the courtroom gallery. Reporters scribbled furiously.
At our table, Marcus Holloway didn't flinch. He leaned over to Julian, whispered a single word—“Now”—and stood up to begin his cross-examination.
“Ms. Miller,” Marcus said, walking toward the witness stand with his hands casually in his pockets. “You claim Mr. Vance ordered you to keep the children quiet by any means necessary?”
“Yes! Absolutely!” Beatrice insisted.
Marcus picked up a tablet from our defense table and tapped the screen. “Your Honor, permission to submit Defense Exhibit D-4 into evidence. This is an encrypted audio recording recovered from the Vance estate’s internal security server, timestamped three weeks before Ms. Miller’s arrest.”
Judge Holloway nodded. “Proceed.”
Through the courtroom’s surround-sound speakers, Beatrice’s own voice echoed with chilling, unmistakable clarity:
“If you cry, your father is going to leave you just like your mother did. Your noise is what killed her. Shut your mouths, or you're going back into the dark closet. Mama died because you were too loud.”
May you like
Beatrice froze on the stand, the color draining from her face until she looked like a wax figure.
“Tell me, Ms. Miller,” Marcus said, his voice dropping into a razor-sharp interrogation register as he stepped inches from the witness box. “Was telling five-year-old babies that they murdered their own mother part of your 'strict behavioral containment protocols'? Or was it simply the torture you were paid to inflict by someone else?”
